yes...which if he tries to,shes not gonna forgive him :/

and when does she warm up lol...?

i need someone to side with!!

when she gets a push! lol. (by Greenie)

-.- u cant use greenie as a REAL arguement untill we know FOR SURE arya is rider...

i know. there can be other ways, but this is the one that fits best!

i need help deciding who's right!!!

lol riiiiiiight....maybe to u but not ta me!

look upon the holy sig (mine) and doubt no more. *hypnotizing* lol.

....must we riddle this thread with another ping pong disscussion of whos the next rider :/

*hypnotized* yes, master...

lol. yeah. it's called a debate. you take turns.

lol. who do you think the next rider will be? ur the one who has actually TALKED to CP!

*slaps SaphireSoul* WAKE OUT OF IT MAN!!!!

and whos talked to cp?!!!!????!!??!?!??!?

yes a NEVER ENDING 1!!! which is what i meant by circles within circles(wow this is QUITE off topic...plz answer my original ? plz)

He wouldn't say directly, just this: "You will be slightly suprised, but you will actually be expecting it. All through Eragon and Eldest, there is major foreshadowing of the next Rider..." didn't help me much.

oooohhh u talked to him b4? cool...well that doesnt help me much either :/....lets ask imnc cuz appearantly they find stuff out that has hardly ne evidence...:/

imnc...?[/i]

short for im not crazy...if u debate with them for a while it gets RLLY long to spell thier name out...so BTW TO ALL PPL OF THIS FORUM u may call me spike

i dont have a shortened name...

that quote helps me REALLY well! there is PLENTY of forsadowing for Arya. none for anyone else though. and I HAVE EVIDENCE!!! u r the one w/o any!

Exactly how useful have i been today...!?

to saphire:(lol u do have a short name ) lol appearantly yto imnc alot...to me it just helped me process my thinking on a few tpopics here and there...


to imnc: LOL LIKE I DONT HAVE EVIDENCE!!!!!!!!!!!!!

should i start a new post about the unknown parts of the language or CP juicy info?

yeah but not in the book 3 forum section...try news or sumthiung...

You speak wisely, little one.

- ~
o.o
OFF TOPIC
(raising eyebrow) little one? lol imnc was right u do quote saphira alot

I never really noticed...weird! force of habit...i guess??!!

post it in book rumors. it isn't news.

on topic: no you dont. post it in bullet/numbered format if u have any.

lol SaphireSoul, u've been MORE than helpful!!! and SpikeSniper, u can't ignore a quote! especially one from CP!

yes lol he asid there was foreshadowing to the next rider...roran had foreshadowing too...

1.he was related closely to eragon(he even says he was more hias brother than murtagh)

2.roran promised to help eragon kill the razac(MOST likely in helgrind)(where the egg is MOST LIKELY TO BE)

i'll be here tomorrow too, so if i log off, be here tomorrow. I'll have more Paolini News!

you have no clue what forshadowing is, do you?

1. his relation isn't forsadowing. that doesn't make him any more likely to be rider either.

2. not forsadowing again. it only gives him a more than 0% chance. otherwise, he wouldn't be exposed PERIOD. It does not make him have more of a chance. it just gives him a chance.

smart one imnc!

That's awesome that you actually talk to him. That's gotta be the coolest thing ever!!!

the word gullible springs to mind.

u know, i don't think so. he seems to know alot about CP... and the AL...

you know... we're gettin' off topic. AGAIN! i may not be a mod but i like seeing us on topic (caterpillar I CAN'T BELIEVE I'M SAYING THIS TO A MOD!! ) if Ayra loves Eragon like i think i do, i'll see her spittin' it out while she dies, the blood oath place, or under those stars

when (she won't) she dies....that would be so sad...

The Menoa Tree would be good, or the Starry Glade... the starry glade is more romantic.

if she does die, and hasn't told Eragon about the fact that he loves her, she'll tell at death, as Frodo said in Lord Of The Rings, "dead the truth dies with you"

ok ppl u know that arya said in the AL that she doesnt love him but elves have perfected the art of sayin one thing and mean another so she might love him

true. but, she could have been telling him straight.

I don't love you.

I only like you as a friend.

Hmm... yeah no.

i see what ur sayin but in book three i think that there is goin to be a big whirl wind of stuff with love and life

u know at the end of eldest at the war the elven spell weavers never showed up im supicous about that.

they can't FLY!!! Eragon only made it cuz he can fly on Saphira.

and don't double post.

Ayra is going to die, in the whirlwind of things, she will give life, but die by Galbatorix

well u never know till u read it so i stand by my opinion.

and i stand by mine, mine is not very likely, but possible

aliens can come down and zap Eragon on the spot! ENYTHING IS POSSIBLE!!!!

everyone has their own decision, and mine is Ayra dieing

as is mine

and i think that arya wont get the egg

ARYA MUST DIE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

AND NOT BE RIDER!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

AND NOT LOVE ERAGON!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

SHE JUST BASICALY SHOULD BE CP'S PUNCHING BAG!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

DING DING DING!!!! that sums my theory up

thats horrible! i get that u dnt want her 2 b a rider n all but thats kinda harsh! aryas awesome and she's cp's boxing glove not the punching bag!

ok she MAY not die but the middle 2 are correct

what part of what AnnieBee and i have been saying is not getting through your skulls???

and she has a better chance than anyone else 2 be rider.

i think she does
but she doesn't know she does
or maybe she doesn't love him
but is attracted to him
and that may develop

well hmm...lets see....how bout...oh YEAH!!! the part of her being a rider lol

You don't even have evidence. All your sig says is posibility. Witch is EVERY charactor is. No more or less then the other.

lol do u read minds? lol u like said exactly what im trying to say

ahhhhhhh! more people who support the roran rider theory! someone shoot me!!!!!!!!!!

When did I say I believe Roran is the rider? First off, I just said that there's no more proof for one person then there is for another. Second, I hope Nasuada's the next rider. Hope, not believe. I don't believe in believing.

why do u hope nasuada is the next rider? shes the leader of the varden and who else would take her place

That dude from the Coucncil of Elders.

I WASN'T TALKING ABOUT THE RIDER THEORY!!!!!!!!! does anyone know if i would get away with insulting you in latin and japanese? cuz i REALLY want to right now. and i know how.

2 shadowagent 0: MOST of it is making it more possible, but forshadowing stands as evidence. and Roran has like 1/4 of the possibility of Arya or LESS!!! don't doubt it. it's true.


This is a warning!!
IMNC, you need to stop the baiting, if you cannot post with civility, you will be admonished!!

come on two human riders
there has to be an elf at sone point

i stick to the fact that she was being her true self as the party
when she kissed him
those were her feelings
clearly expressed
but now denied

FOR THE LAST FRIGGEN TIME!!!

I DO NOT THINK RORAN IS THE NEXT RIDER!!!

I THINK NASUADA IS THE NEXT RIDER!!!

And as for foreshadowing, WHAT FORESHAOWING?

ALL YOUR "EVIDENCE" IS JUST SPECULATION!!!

THERE'S NO FORESHADOWING AT ALL!!!

Oh, but...but Arya is well trained!

WELL SO IS ORIK, RORAN, NASUADA, ANGELA!!!

AND ERAGON COULD ONLY USE A BOW BEFORE HE BACAME RIDER!!!

AND HE WASN'T THAT GOOD!!!

And once again because you are to thick skulled to get this, I DO NOT, NOR HAVE I EVER, NOR WILL I, THINK RORAN IS THE NEXT RIDER!!!

Maybe that got thru.

Oh, AND WHEN DID SHE KISS HIM!?!

I know what foreshadowing is you moron.

This is a warning!!
Shadowagent, you need to stop the name calling, it goes against our forum rules in regards to respect.
AnnieBee

you were saying???

I could think of some names to call yuo but I would get banned.

I think you think I said WHAT'S forshadowing. I said WHAT forshadowing. Moron.

And Nasuada is only good at swordfighting? I just said Eragon was only good with a bow.

And Dwarves just don't WANT to be in the spell. Orik says it in Eldest. He also says that flying on Saphira was a good experience witch shows he isn't scared of the idea anymore like the other dwarves are.

And Roran has more than proven himself with a hammer. He is good at somthing to.

They are all good warriors.

oh. ok. w/e. and even calling me a moron is unacceptable, so you might want to watch yourself further.

She is, but she doesn't have the kind of time Eragon had to learn everything else. speaking of which, NOONE HAS TIME TO TRAIN MUCH!!! Thusly, the most likely candidates are ELVES.

and her eyes and magic are both forshadowing of her getting the green dragon. don't you pay attention?!?!?!

So he's good w/ a hammer. He's not going to go around on dragon-back swinging a HAMMER!!! and sinse that is his only battle-experience, he has no real experience. at least Eragon could use a bow!

He can also use a spear.

And Nasuada isn't the only one who can lead the Varden.

And I notice you didn't say anything about Orik.

And Arya doesn't really want to go back to Ellesmera. She was so eager to leave. And BEFORE YOU SAY ANYTHING, she wanted to go LONG before she new Eragon liked her.

And Paolini said at an interview that a rider doesn't need to have the same magic color as dragons. This is bacause they can bend their magic into any color they want. Also a fact stated by Paolini.

he'd not going to use a spear on dragon-back either.

she is the best suited to lead the Varden.

i said that it is impossible because the Dwarves weren't included in the spell. and he liked flying some, but he would rather be on solid land if he can help it.

she did say "It suits me." when Eragon said that she was pleased being around her own people. she wasn't eager to leave, but she knew it was her duty.

it doesn't DETERMINE a rider, but it IS forsadowing.

No it's a charactoristic.

And isn't there a thread for this already?

And again, When did she kiss him?

if she did, I'd jump for joy, but i don't remember jumping. lol.

what's characteristic?

Her magic being green. It's just a charatoristic. If there where forshadowing it would be a big event told in great detail. I bet Paolini doesn't want to skimp.

how is that characteristic??? it could have as easily been another color, but he probably picked green for a REASON. and forshadowing doesn't have to be all in your face w/ a neon sign saying IT'S FORSHADOWING!!!

But I don't think Paolini would want to make it a small scene. And maybe her eyes are green because elves dress in green. Paolini was only 15 when he made book 1.

you aren't CP are you? how are YOU to know if he wanted it to be obvious or not?!

Eragon has red elven clothing. they don't just dress in green.

he may have came up with the idea at 15, but his writing skills have developed sinse then..... i hope.

Look, these are the best books ever made. EVER! But let's face it, Paolini isn't that good. If we got someone who could describe situations a little better, I'm sure everyone would have the same opinions because everything isn't confusing. The question is though, what opinions would we all have?

the concept and storyline are THE BEST, but i agree, the writing is a bit amature. actually, people arguing over what is going to happens means that he did a GOOD job keeping things a bit mysterious.

Yeah, but there are far to much arguments. There is one person for each possibility. I even heard some idiot say Galbatorix and Elva would get together. "Caughs nervousley"

I'm surprised no one suggested a Angela\Eragon relationship yet. I'm not saying I believe that in ANY way, I'm just surprised no one came up with that.

There should only be a couple debates to each problem.

you can do couple debates for EVERY book!!! couple debates aren't worth making forums for. Inheritence is more intereting, creating more involved plot lines and creating more uncertain possibilies. THAT is where CP has truly excelled.

Angela/Eragon........ *shudder* don't say that near AnnieBee or else she'll hurl on you! lol. she sickened by thinking of Arya/Eragon. i can't emagine what she thinks of Angela/Eragon.... lol.

Hey, I just thought of something.

How old is Angela?

If we figure that out it could prove and disprove many theorys.

She is pretty old because she knew Brom from the past and he is pretty old.

she is older than she seems, which means probably beyond 50. that's my guess.

I agree way beyond 50.

not WAAAAY beyond, just like 20 years beyond max, unless she turns out to be an ex-rider, which would be unexpected.

Yeah but she is a witch and witches live to be pretty old.

not really. it just says that she has taken her own medicines and herbs when times were hard. most witches probably don't have to do that.

Wait, is this on topic. SPAMMERS! SPAMMERS I SAY! Oh, and no she doesn't love Eragon. I'm on topic.

Aren't Spammers those who just post one word? And if you are right I don't care.

Maybe she secretly loves him deep deep down.

yeah she does, just deep down.

spammers are people who post overly-short posts. not getting off topic.

Then how were we spammers?

If that's true then why should I keep it down?

we arent! that is my point. let's get back on topic.

Ok we are and yes deep deep down she loves Eragon.

We where never on topic. And Arya does not love Eragon.

Yes she does deep deep deep deep down down down.

don't go too down! lol. as he said deep deep deep deep down.

Everybody loves everybody deep deep deep deep deep down.

If it's anymore, they hate each other so your wrong about that and just offended your own case.

She has about three deeps, that's family love. It slips thru sometimes but is never serious. Just like family. They'd be like a bro and sis. Eww. Sicko.

The exceptable grades are 1,2 and 4 deeps.

4 deeps is hidden love. What I believe Nasuada and Eragon to be at. That is possible to grrow into love.

2 deeps is very good friends who went to far or hurt each other and are now awkward aroud each other. Murtagh and Nasuada are most likely at this, this is unlikely to grow but I admit still possible.

1 deep is people who are dating. You can't know when it will pass thru but it definatley will. No one is at this right now.

Right after deep loves is love. If just love is present, you slowed down. This is how come 3 deeps is never able to grow. Once you slow down at 3 deeps and love, you can't get going again because they are comfortable to be at. 3 deeps can become love ocasionaly but never more. This is Roran's spot with Eragon, this is where family sits at. But Roran might have been bumped to 2 deeps or might be stuck at 3 deeps forever after Garrow died. If family goes to 2, they skip 1 but will always end up at love again.

Deeply in love is the money spot. This is what 1, 2 and 4 deeps have to pray they reach. If they don't quick enough, they get stuck at 3 deeps and love, and never get here. Those who do, are here forever.

2 deeplys is a very bad place to be. This is stalker land. You don't want to be at stalker land.

Everyone else is at 5 deep downs, just friends. This is also where everyone marks from the first time they meet. Can grow to 4, but it has to be borderline 5 from the start.

I hope you liked my little explination, this took me a long while to type.

that's not true. everybody doesn't love everybody.

they don't hate each other!!! Y is she friends with him then? Y does she give him like.... 3 chances?

3 deeps doesn't equal family. it just has to do with how latent and/or un-selfunderstood her love is for him.

there is NO rule system for "deeps" in love. i don't know where you found this, cuz it's crud, or i can't believe you would make something like this up to suit your own scheme.

actually, i think your explination is total garbage!!! that is totally made up to suit your own scheme and argument. that has NOTHING to do with ANYTHING and has NO credibility whatsoever.

Yeah well...shut up.