I'm new to the forums and not sure if this has been brought up before yet. Anybody else think that it's possible for Eragon and Nasuada to get together? Angela's fortune did say that he will fall in love with royalty. All throughout the book Eragon it was basically given that he was to fall in love with Arya. Although in Eldest...the way that Nasuada always talks to Eragon, the way they interact with each other...possible for them to get together? For some reason, the idea hit me while reading the final battle in Eldest. She's royalty as well you know. It would be a good turn of events, seeing as how Christopher has tried to get us to think Arya will be his love, switching it to Nasuada would be a good twist.

good idea! maybe thats what will happen although when Angela told him his thingy she said he would fall in love not some one would fall in love wit him, right now he seems pretty rapped-up in arya, but you could be right! [/u]

i like it. by the way this has been brought up before but it dosent matter. i like the way ur thinking and u could be right. keep it up

I don't know, I think Eragon will stick with Arya, but anything is possible.

yea really

I hoping Murtagh will go with Nasuada, and Eragon will still stick to Arya. It might be a nice twist but Angela said he would fall for someone of noble birth

I don't think Arya will fall for Eragon. Angela said that he would be in love with someone of noble birth, most likely Arya, but she said nothing of her loving him back. She said she couldn't see how it ended. So this could be the love she was talking about.
And I'm not so sure about Nasuada either. I think she'll fall in love with someone else, or get killed on the battlefield... I dont know, I really don't think she'll get with Eragon though.

ya and arya said she didnt want to love him because she didnt want to distract him from his job or something like that

yea really

I think that Arya does have feelings for Eragon, but she's hiding them out of fear. I think that she was in love with Faolin, one of the elves Durzan killed, so maybe she's still getting over that loss and is afraid of falling in love again. Or maybe she just doesn't realize that she loves him yet... like Pride and Prejudice. I don't think Eragon and Nasuda will get together. Their relationship doesn't express that to me. She isn't really of noble birth either, though we don't know her bloodline, where her father and mother came from.

i agree. she loved that elf and when she learnd of his death she was in pain like losing someone really close and if she startsliking eragon and he dies she wopuld go through pain againand she dosent want that to happen again.

whoa i never thought odf that before i mean i knew that nasuada was royal but i never really thought anout it....man there is alot of smart people in this chat.

I thought about that but i didn't like it because ialways thought that Murtagh loved her. She loved him, she was crying at the end of eldest 4 him ... and eragon doesn't deserve her. lol, idk...idk, itcould happen

But if Eragon and Nasuada hook up that would be kinda hard for Eragon bc he would live longer than her! So idk!!!!!

thats true. Though if she becomes the 3rd Rider (though i dont want it to be her.) she would live as long as Eragon.

yea idk i think roran might be the new rider

The sooner the third book comes out the sooner we will all know and then we will all talk about what we thought of our Author's choices. Makes ya go Hmmmmmmm!

i don't know but i really doubt Nasuada will end up with Murtagh seeing as in he is wiht the empire and all. and i don't really think Nasuada will get together with Eragon either.

im bored......................

I really hope that Eragon and Nasuada get together, and that Nasuada rides the green dragon. Because, Eragon and Arya are dumb. Like teeny-bopper LotR.

lol, good one... It's a good theory that Eragon and Nasuada will get together, but I have my doubts, though Angela said that Eragon will fall in love with someone of noble birth, so i wont nasuada out...

I do not think Eragon and Nusuada would get togeather because of thier Posistions

Iv mentioned it in passing before, but it seems Eragon has fallen for arya, still a whole book. Im glad other people have similar theorys to me.

Well Eragon is said to fall in love with someone of noble birth doesnt mean he will marry or have a child with said Noble born person

i think it fairly unlikely that Eragon would fall in love with Nasuada because, like a lot of people said, Eragon hardly thought of Nasuada while he was in Ellesmera. I dont think i like the pairing of Murtagh with Nasuada as he turned out to be against the Varden during the battle at the end of the book Eldest.

nasuada is what? 3 years older, arya is over 80 years older

i still hope that eragon and arya get together evan that u know there is quite an age diff.

No i dont think he will, Nasuada is not of noble birth and eragon said he would not get together with anyone that would not live as long as him or way to old for him-(like ayra)

yeah, i agree mostly. Nasuada isnt really royal, she is a leader of the vaden, not a queen or something.

Nasuda is more than OK, she's the future Queen.. But its not likely for eragon to marry nasuada because eragon vow to her and now he's her "bodyguard" so.. well.. don think so

LOL I think there is a film with Kevin Costner named Personal guard (or something like that)

i think eragon has it for Arya.

eragon fancys arya nasuda fancys murtagh ang roran fancys katrina

Hate pairing like this it's so predictible

In Eragon I thought Murtgag was developing a crush for Nasuada and in Eldest when she infers that Murtag was the new rider she is full of sorrow. I don't think that after the events of the battle there may be any chance for Murtag and Nasuada. Somehow I can't see Eragon being so fickle but I cannot visualize Arya changing her mind. So I really am lost to who the wise, noble woman Angela predicted will be. Your theory is an excellent one, BUT we will all have to wait and see.

i kind of thought more of Nasuada and Murtagh during the short time they were with each other
Eragon just doesn't feel that way about Nasuada
She might like him though...
It just won't ever be returned

Yeah, I know there cannot be anything between Murtag and Nasuada. I don't have a clue if CP will have anyone willing to pair with Nasuada by the end of the series.
I constantly keep thinking of the dream Eragon had in which a couple boarded a ship and a solitary man cried out to the wind as the ship sailed away and two dragons were seen flying in the air...
I know that one of dragons is bound to be Saphira and I think the other may be the 3rd egg hatched to start a new race of dragons but who can the couple be? Who can the lonely man be? Could it be Arya and Eragon and Murtag on the shore? Could it be Roran and Katrina sailing away and Eragon left behind? Could the 3rd egg hatch for Arya? Could Roran be the rider for the last egg? So many questions unanswered.

me too
i think it is when he leaves never to return...
but that probably means Murtagh lives

OOOOPPS! Yes I forgot that little detail about the prophecy. Eragon will leave Alagaesia to never return. So Eragon must be the one leaving on the ship.

well blue dragon and the other one is green

That is one of the clues that lead me to believe that the egg may hatch for Arya. Her magic force is green.
I have to go & pick up the grandkids from school so I'll be off for a little. I'll be back to discuss this in more detail.

but that means the romance doesn't work!!!!!!!!!


sorry i may seem a bit dark but I'm a romantic at heart

No, maybe Arya and Eragon are the two who sail away, but who is the one that stays behind?
Don't blame you at all. I love happy, sappy endings too!

maybe Nasuada will be on her own

For the moment, I do see her alone unless.. (AND PLS DO NOT HARP ON ME) unless King Orin gets his act together, leaves all his goofiness behind and falls in love with her!

i highly doubt that Orin with straighten up

I don't think Orin would be a good match for Nasuada. She is so determine, smart, strong, logical. She is everything Orin isn't.

and Orrins realy old

No, he is not thast old. Actually he is five years older than Nasuada. This fact is given to us when Nasuada moves the Varden to Surda.

there not suited for each other

Nope, not at all. I have to go now. I can't find the rubber bands to tie my grand daughters hair and she wants me to take her out to blow some bubbles. So see you later.

bye

Please try not to have one word posts.

how do you know nasuada is not of noble birth?
you don't knoe who her mother is.

Orin and Nasuada
Nasuada and Murtagh
Which one makes more sense

Nasuda and Murtagh makes sense

They both make sense.

but Murtagh and Nasuda are more likely

Why? Murtagh's gone evil remember.

but he could live and be good

or hes dies and nasuada will like eragon but hes busy trying to win arya

[quoting "Ayrareincarnated"]Orin and Nasuada
Nasuada and Murtagh
Which one makes more sense[/quotThe Orin thought was a joke.
If Murtagh had not killed King Hrothgar, I would have thought he could redeem himself some time later in the 3rd book. Now I think he is way beyond this point.
It's a pity, because it was hinted that there was a possibility of a romance to spark between the two of them.


I think Nasuada is way too smart and mature for Orin, even though she is five years younger than him. Besides she is one hell of a leader and way too self-sufficient and independent for an oddball like Orin.

I only saw a spark from his side. He was talking about her bearing. The only thing she has done was visit him once, and that was the first time they met.

I think they will, I bet Ayra will die somehow.

Oh my God! Eragon the 1st elf it's been such a long time since I've seen you on the site! Welcome back!


im a roc:Arya cannot die. That would be as if Eragon died. They have to end up together by the end of the series.



I'MNOTCRAZY I only saw a spark from his side. He was talking about her bearing. The only thing she has done was visit him once, and that was the first time they met.

Who are you talking about?

IM TALKING ABOUT THE TOPIC!!! AND WHAT YOU WERE TALKING ABOUT LAST!!!!!!!!

This is what I'M talking about. I did not understand anything on it! When did sparks began to fly? Where was I , that I missed it?

No, you didn't. Nothing will become of Nasuada and Eragon except for a good friendship and bond. We already know that Eragon loves Arya and I don't think his feelings will ever change, even towards Nasuada. I think that he respects and honors her for who she is but I never saw any sort of relationship or sparks between the two of them. I saw that more with Eragon and Arya rather than Nasuada and him. Nope, I doubt anything will happen between the two of them...they will remain allies and very close and good friends.

Yeah I remember that. He seems to have feelings towards her or something. If anything it would be him and Nasuada rather than Eragon and Nasuada.

i think eragon is likely either arya or nasuada.
but arya n eragon has age problem

eragon and nasuada could get together, and arya find out and get jelous.
nasuada and murtagh wont happen because he told galbatorix everything he knew about the varden, remember? he betrayed nasuada to galby, and i dont think she will find that attractive!

Sense this is my first post I need to start with something that will show everyone that i'm a friend.

You guys are ******* Friendly enough? Edited by AnnieBee 10/27/06

Of course Eragon and Nasuada are gonna be together. I'll do a Q & A.

Q: Who was the one that squealed out Eragon's name when he came back from Ellesmara?
A: Nasuada

Q: Who was the one who ran to him and hugged him while crying when they found out Eragon was alive?
A: Nasuada

Q: Who was the one the book said Eragon was un-expecting to be so happy to see?
A: Nasuada

Q: Who's the Marie-Sue who broke Eragon's heart?
A: Arya

Q: But didn't the prophecy say Eragon would love someone of noble birth?
A: We don't know anything about Nasuada's mother.

Q: But didn't the prophecy also say he would leave Algaesia forever?
A: Nasuada, Ajihad and that guard are the only black people on Algaesia. She's probably from the continent Eragon sails away to. That might be why he's going, she might leave for there after Galby is gone and the Varden is no longer needed.

Q: Couldn’t that guard is her boyfriend?
A with a Q: From When? She was a baby when she was took to Algaesia. He might have been sent to get her back.

Q: Then why did Ajihad take her?
A: That will probably be explained in book 3.

THE Q YOU'VE ALL BEEN WAITING FOR: What about Murtagh?
A: She was just as relieved that Eragon was alive as she was upset that Murtagh was evil if not more. She carries an equally light torch for each (again if not more for Eragon) of them.

There you go.

Don't be rude.

Nasuada squealed his name because he was the one who was going to be able to save the whole of surda and the varden.

She hugged him because she was gald he was alive- he is their only hope.

Eragon still loves Arya even though she said no.

Arya is of noble birth- far more noble than Nasuada

Could you translate the guard/boyfriend bit into English please?

And quit the insults or you get a warning.

caterpillar THANK YOU FIRETOUNG!!!! u just saved me a lot of typing. lol. nice.

who is practically perfect (or at least from Eragon's point of view)?
Arya.

who does Eragon love and refuse to give up his love over?
Arya.

Who is Eragon's liegelord making any love between them morally wrong?
NASUADA!!!

I had fealiing nobody would listen. It's near impossible to change the mind of some one on a forum. You can't put a lot of thought into her being his leigelord. They only did that to block out the council from controlling him. He may still love Arya but face it, she doesn't love him. When Elva tried to convince him not to fix his curse until after the battle because he would get tired, who's name did she use? She could of used Arya's name but Nasuada getting hurt or dieing would cause more emotional pain for him. Don't say she could of said that to protect Nasuada directly. Eragon was far closer and I think I remember him holding Elva's shoulders or somthing. She would have picked up every pain from him and every pain from anyone else would be drowned out.

NOT TRUE!!! i convince people ALL THE TIME! and you CAN put a lot of thought into that. there really can't be a relationship between them. And Arya may love him deep down. she may have just not relized her feelings, and thusly believes that she doesn't, though noting the change in her at the end of Eldest, she may have realized it. it wasn't because of the emotional pain, but because Nasuada is his liegelord.

This one took me a while to find the words but I think I got a comeback,

If you CAN say the only reason Nasuada and Eragon like each other so much is bacause of fealty, then why doesn't Murtagh like Galbatorix? Eragon was forced to give fealty to keep Nasuada in charge of the Varden, and Murtagh was just forced to give fealty. Eragon and Nasuada weren't friends when he gave fealty. They only met one time before that, so he was pledging fealty for Ajihad really. The fealty can discount some fealings but not all of it. Nowhere near all of it.

the thing about that is that they can be friends, but their positions do not morally allow for a relationship beyond that. And Eragon doesn't seem like the kind of guy who will say to himself, "i didn't get her, so I'll forget about her and go for someone else".

Eragon never liked Arya more then a little crush or infatuation. It's more like a little girl meeting some lead singer in a band then two destined lovers meeting. Eragon was only attracted to Arya for her physical features. And how do the positions of Nasuada and Eragon affect them having a relationship any more then the positions of Arya and Eragon. And besides, there's nothing saying Nasuada and Eragon can't get together after Galb is gone and the Varden isn't needed any more.

I have a split theory, Paolini wrote Eragon when he was 15, he was young immature and filled with more hormones then a (insert funny and riskay comment here). Nearing the end of Eragon his teenage angst was wearing off and he realized everything he thought to be so perfect about Arya was her body. That's why he made him and Nasuada hit it off in their first meeting. The reason book two was focused on the Arya\Eragon relationship was because Paolni didn't want to ruin all the set-up book 1 did for their relationship. He tried to give Arya a personality but when he realized it was to late he had her flat-out reject Eragon. So in the end of Eldest he shrunk the Arya\Eragon relationship and skyrocketed the Nasuada\Eragon relationship. Now the odds of relationships is,

Nasuada\Eragon- 50%

Arya\Eragon- 50%

He's undecided on who to make the relationship finale with and wants it open for each.

he's WAAAAAY beyond a little crush! He WAS just infatuated, but as Eldest progressed, it turned into something more. don't get me wrong: he's still infatuated with her. it's just that it's accompanied by truer love.

Eragon and Nasuada were NOT hitting it off! and now that she is his liege, it is morally wrong for them to have a relationship.

And it's not morraly wrong to have a relationship with someone over a hundred years old?

it would be if she was human, but that not being the case, human morals do not apply to Elves. and it's not like she's an old bag.

u know how boss' aren't supposed to date their employee's? SAME THING HERE!

All right, there's where your wrong.

They said in one of the books (Eldest I think, when they where in the canoe going to Ellesmera) that it was all right to ignore such an age difference between a human and an elf because human's don't live as long. But they also said that sense Eragon was now a rider and would live as long as elves, the age difference would matter. I think, and this is really gonna push some buttons, Nasuada will be the next rider.

caterpillar. u just pushed the wrong button near the wrong person. u just put me into 'heated debate mode'. state ur argument or prepare to be vituperated for not having one. lol. i like that word.

the thing about the age thing is that it doesn't matter if they love each other!

First off, Arya said herself that it would be an abomination, not morally wrong, full fledged ABOMINATION!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

1. As you said, not real proof. Paolini said himself that the riders dragon had nothing to do with the riders magic color. Magic could be bent to any color the user wants. Plus, when did the book say Arya's magic was green? When did the book even show Arya use magic?

2. Just because she's good doesn't mean she's the next rider.

3. See answer 2. Plus so is Nasuada.

4. See previouse posts to reaalize that I neither beleive Eragon and Arya arte in love nor CP thinks it neccesary for them to be.

I can't give evidence to Nasuada being the next rider because it doesn't make sense. There isn't one charactor who should be the rider. I just guessed Nasuada because then her and Eragon's love would go on forever. No evidence or reason exists at all. CP swears it's oviouse but I just can't find out who he's talking about. I know the following,

It's someone from or mentioned in book 1 and 2.

It's someone nobody guessed yet sense it's supposed to be that thing where it can't be discovered by anyone but wont suprise them when they read it. People will just go, "oh I see". Not "caterpillar I NEVER GUESSED THAT!" Or "Called it! I rule, who rules, why I do."

And it's someone who is not Arya.

Okay the last ones just to tick you off.

NO NO NO NO NO!!!! she said that if she shared her memories it would be an abomination.

1. she uses green magic at least twice. and it is FORSADOWING!!!
2. it makes her more likely! she needs no/little training! time is of the essence
3. she is NOWHERE near as good as Arya!
4. it would be VERY good in the book and she has shown some evidence of feelings for him

THEY HAVE NO LOVE!!! NASUADA DOESN'T LOVE HIM AND VISA VERSA!!!

true

not true. it can be guessed. if it isnt, it would be a total shock.

you did just tick me off. and no evidence loses MISERABLY in a debate.

Well to bad YOU DON'T HAVE ANY REAL EVIDENCE!!!!!

IT'S JUST YOUR BELEIF!!!!

I'M TIRED OF US CONSTTINTLEY SAYING THE WORDS DOESN'T AND DOES!!!!!

NONE OF US KNOW ANYHING!!!!

I DON'T KNOW NASUADA AND ERAGON ARE IN LOVE, IT'S MY BELEIF!!!

YOU DON'T KNOW ARYA AND ERAGON ARE IN LOVE OR THAT SHE'S THE NEW RIDER, IT'S YOUR BELEIF!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

NO MORE SAYING , DOES, DOESN'T, IS, ISN'T, WILL OR WONT!!!!!

I GUARENTEE THAT IF WE KEEP FIGHTING, EVENTUALLY SOMEONE'S HEAD IS GONNA ROLL!!!

AND IT'S MY BELEIF THAT IT'LL BE YOUR'S!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

That's why my sig translate,

May fate be strong for Nasuada and Eragon.

Eragon does hold Nasuada's heart to Eragon's.

I couldn't find the word for his.

stop shouting. really. it's annoying, not to mention rude.

there is NO evidence that they are in love. it is not even SUGGESTED.

I know that Eragon loves Arya and will not go for anyone else. She seems to love Eragon at the end of Eldest. that's more than Nasuada has! C, the thing is, w/o evidence, you don't have an argument. it's just oppinion. WITH evidence, it is a theory. theories are better than oppinions.


who said we were fighting? i was DEBATING. maybe YOU were fighting.

hey! what happened to no saying "does"?! you say it in your sig!!!

Are you thw worlds most stubborn ******? Edited by AnnieBee 10/27/06
I'm saying I have an opinion. And so do you. I have evidence, but it's my opinion that it's evidence. Your evidence is also only evidence in your and anyone with your beleifs, eyes.

My opinion is that Nasuada loves Eragon in the end of Eldest because of the hug, smiling and excitement she showed.

Your opinion is that Arya loves Eragon in the end for whatever reason you see fit.

I'm w\o evidence and your w\o evidence.

I think I have evidence bacause my opinion makes me think that.

You think you have evidence because your opinion makes you think so.

We can go on forever trading are evidence and not get anywhere.

CP is the only one who has the evidence. That evidence is book 3.

He could go to a press conference, and flat out say, Eragon and Arya are in love, Arya is the next rider, they shall make sweet sweet love down by the fire.

And after that, I still would beleive Nasuada would end up with Eragon because the only evidence is the unfinished book.

So I guess I should get used to typing because we're gonna be "debating" for a long time.

And another thing, debating is a verbal battle. A battle is a fight. We are therefor fighting. So excuse me if that was the first word I thought of.

And another thing, your right about my sig saying does in it. That goes with my opinion though. I am at falt for putting that there but will not change it because that means changing my opinion.

And another thing, your feet smell.

i understand that it's ur oppinion. ok.

so? can't she be happy that her friend is not dead, when she had thought the contrary a moment before?! i would be!

ok. i understand that that is "opinion". (really it's a theory, but i'll humor you)

not true.

not really. see below

no. i have evidence, not because of my oppinion, but becasue it supports my opinion. my oppinion does not make me think it is evidence.

ur right. u r too stuborn and I'm 2 good at this! lol. jk. but i am good at this.

y don't I ask SaphiraSoul? he KNOWS CP.

he could, but that would make the release less suspenseful. BUT that would be AWSOME!!! lol.

now THAT is where you PROVE that you are stuborn. even if CP flat-out said that Arya will be the next rider and she will be in love with Eragon, you would STILL doubt it.

and yeah. i am.

it is not a battle unless you take it personally. i only take it personally when others take it personally, OR they are being plain stupid.

and no they don't. wow. that was random.

YOU R WRONG!!! YOU R DEAD WRONG!!!! YOUR FEET DO SMELL!!!

And also, my evidence supports my opinion. But it's still an opinion. I wanna here your so called evidence. Go ahead, I mean if it's so great.

for what? the next rider, Arya loving Eragon, Brom being Eragon's father? what?

Let's start with Arya loving Eragon.

ok. the POSIBILITY is there because, even though she said that she doesn't love him in the AL, she could have feelings for him deep down, and she doesn't understand/recognize/realize them. She pushes Eragon away because of the reasons stated by Oromis.

The evidence is that at the end of Eldest, she seems to have a change of heart. She acts drastically different than previously in the book. Most notably, she hesitates when she leaves him, instead of doing what is expected and not turning back, as she would do if she was still angry with him.

Alright, acceptable. But still an opinion. Your opinion is she likes him more than she did previously. It shows they've grown closer, that leaves it to the opinions. You think they got so close they're in love, I think she just trusts him to keep away.

When they first talked, Nasuada was strict and to the point. She was very professional. During the war chapters, she is running up to him and getting real close when they talk, the two express worry for each other (though I surrender that to fealty), she gets overjoyed and hugs him when they realize he's alive (I might add Arya kept her spot), the book said Eragon was unprepared for how happy he was to see Nasuada, Nasuada (and giving Arya as well, but Nasuada cupped his face to comfort him) comforted Eragon when they found out Murtagh was his bro and Morzan was his pa (and she also expressed being over Murtagh and capable of fighting him) and finally, Eragon and Nasuada are always comforting each other and making each other smile. Look it up, there isn't a single time they've met where one of them hasn't smiled.

It is clear that they've grown to close for her to be professional when they meet (and vise versa), but it's only my opinion (as stated earlier) that they grew close enough to be in love.

I already have seen your Arya is the next rider evidence so unless you have any more, move on to Brom.

that doesn't explain why she hesitated.

she gets real close? can you quote that? she thinks he is dead. Eragon is her friend. if i thought that my friend was dead then he appears out of nowhere, then I'd be overjoyed 2! Arya is trying to sort through her confused emotions about Eragon and restrains herself from showing ANY emotion. A friend, which no doubt she is to him, would show SOME emotion, but her retraint shows that she was restraining something more. The book says that he is unprepared for how happy he is to see BOTH women. cupped his face? And Arya comforts him too. not in the same way, but she does nonetheless. So? they comfort each other. Friends do that. And smiling has nothing to do with love. not really. you can smile with your friends.

has Eragon displayed or even THOUGHT of loving Nasuada? NO! i don't understand how you can think that Eragon is going to dump his strong love for Arya and spontaneously start loving Nasuada.


Now: brom... there is ALOT of evidence. lemme post it....

Brom said, “She was full of dignity and pride, like Garrow. Ultimately it was her downfall, but it was one of her greatest gifts nevertheless. . . . She always helped the poor and the less fortunate, no matter what her situation.” He answered to Eragon’s question, “You knew her well?”, “Well enough to miss her when she was gone.” Also, Blagden said “Son and father alike, both as blind as bats” after being asked what his first prophesy ment. This denotes that Blagden had met Eragon's father. Morzan had never gone to Ellesmera, though Brom had. On pg. 435 of Eragon, Angela saya, "He (Brom) loved a woman, but it was his affection which was her undoing." Selena finally realizes thta Morzan is using her. She wants revenge. She may have been helping the Varden when she meets Brom, or the other way around: she meets Brom, falls in love with him, and helps the Varden by helping Brom get the egg, as well as take down others of the Wyrdfell. She was carrying Brom's child and Morzan found out OR she fears that he will do the same to this baby as Murtagh. She runs away went to Carvahall. Then Galby sends a legion after her and they go into the spine. somehow they all die and she is barely living. She goes back to Carvahall and has Eragon. She then runs off again, and either goes back to the castle directly, Morzan dead, or he's alive and he captures her. If he is alive, he kills Selena, then the enraged Brom goes and kills Morzan. If Morzan is dead, then Selena probably had a part in it. Then Brom goes to Carvahall to keep an eye on his son. Garrow kinda blames him for the death of Selena, so he moves from town. Either that, or to protect him: if Brom is found, then Eragon will be safe.

I respected that bs story you called evidence. But all you do is trash mine? uh-uh. Out of a fit of rage I shall say something really stupid and completely (in my opinion) un true. What if the reason Arya didn't get up was because the elves secretly want Eragon dead and she was upset that he was still alive?

Now on to stuff I do believe, To explain some things, when I say Nasuada and Eragon are always talking so close to each other, I meant that in the final chapters of Eldest, one or the other runs up to the other and gets real close. While when Arya and Eragon talk, they're only close when events make it. As for cupping his face, she did that thing where you put your hand on someone’s face to show support and love for the person. If your friends are giving you that kind of comfort, I would back away. And think about the story of the Menoa Tree. The man loved a woman so much older then him and thought he was in love. Until the man started having urges to be with a woman his own age. That (in my opinion) is what happened with Eragon. Eragon himself said they where not a fit couple, so he subconsciously agreed that the age difference was to great.

As for Brom, this is how I reacted as I read your theory.

caterpillar
lol
...
wtf
caterpillar

Bravo. Your opinion is now my opinion.

Now then, give me evidence to why I should believe your feet don't smell.

no. i already stated my story. you trashed it, then u put your story, then i trashed it. we're even and i doubt that we'll get any farther.

i didn't notice that. maybe 2mar0 u can quote it from the book. Arya is not close because of recent events. you would feel uncomfortable w/ the other person even if you DO love him/her! lol. and can you quote the cupping part? i want to read it first hand.

the menoa tree thing? well, elves weren't immortal then, so they probably aged 2. Thusly, it doesn't really apply, other than it fitted when Eragon was not turned immortal. and he said that they weren't a fit couple, not because of age, but because of how they acted.

as for Brom: SCORE ONE FOR I'MNOTCRAZY!!! lol.

And your feet come in where?

The cupping of the face is when Arya and Nasuada are assuring Eragon that it's okay Morzan is his dad. (Wich he isn't )

Final chapter
Page 663
Fourth paragragh

And in the paragragh followig, he look back and forth between Arya and Nasuada who both had assured him, and I believe that shows his feelings are a straight cut 50\50 mix for each one. It could go either way, I just think it should go to Nasuada.