Maybe Elva the girl Eragon acidently cursed will become the rider beacuase of the mark Saphira gave her you know?

thank you i mean ormis said a person with a riders mark but is not a rider maybe when she might get the dragon she would get 2 marks doubling her magic power.

I always thought Elva was a minor character, and she would drop out of the main action after Eragon manages to reverse the effect of his invocation upon her. Perhaps i guess she could do other stuff

idk....i mean i always thought her to play a different important role in the 3rd book but i guess u never know...

No she doesnt partcularly like eragon because of the curse. And he's sorry bout it. Ther friends nothin more

elva isnt gunna be a rider. Roran, Nausuada and my fav one Arya are the only candidates i believe

all im saying is they dont have to get together but maybe she will become the rider beacuase she has the mark i mean you never know......especially with the surprises cp pulls on u

Cp wont do that to us.. I dont like Elva, i hope she dies trying to save someone

well arent u nice one other thing how would nadusa be a rider thats like adding to her problems cuz then she would have to fight and she also has to control the varden to

she doesnt have to fight she could be like galby sit on her throne gain power. You arent bound to do any task as a rider. You govern yourself unless other comitments but its gunna be arya

sure maybe but these are OPINIONS note: OPINIONS all im saying is an idea it doesnt have to come true

im not saying your opinion is wrong im just saying you dont have much proof to back it.

that is the point OPINION your not supposed to have evidence its just an idea. besides i have a shread of evidence elva is marked with a riders sign and as ormis said a person whos not a rider but has the gedway insignia.

If you re-read eragon you will notice that it says its not a shinning palm but a shinning star on her forehead, i know that Dragons are a peculiar species but when saphira touched eragon for the first time it didnt appear where she touched him but on his right hand. But on this occurance it wasnt on the palm but where saphira touched her. The gedway insignia means shinning palm and its a term only for riders thus meaning that she is not a rider, not yet see not bashing your opininon still a sliver of hope

the gedway insignia is praticly a star but...it was on eragons palm it dosent have to be a palm it coul be anywhere on your body as long as the dragon touches you there

sorry but it means shinning palm so i believe it would be on your palm

what im trying to say is words are adaptadble witch means that you could say shining fore head or shinig cheast

but then it wouldnt be an Argetalam which the gedway insignia is a nessecity

what im saying is they could put shining with any body part as long as they had the knowledge for the word

But with a dragon rider it must be the palm, they arent gunna say shinning forhead that effing rude lol. Its prolly gunna be arya or roran i must repeat that

how is shining forehead rude and two maybe but all ive got is opinions im not gonna stalk cp and like hack the computer or anything im only 11

ok i grow tired of repeating this so im done with this topic it bores me much because im almost certain that it wont be elva and im tired of trying to persuade you so there you go u win its gunna be elva

that was just my opinion what i thought would happen not what i wanted to happen *master dude voice* you have muct to learn about debating my young one

hmmm but you dont have much to say that elva will be the rider because the shinning forehead already had its effect on her because of the blessing. She is like that because the blessing that eragon gave her and the mark is just that a mark. So please tell me why it "CANT" be Arya and Roran., If every1 is lucky they all get dragons and then they form a family bond but thats not gunna happen its gunna be 1 other for the next generation and its gunna not be elva because she has no reason to be a dragon rider. Also if shes still cursed she will kill her and her dragon instently because she will throw herself to save anything and die for it. But if the curse is lifted then she will be like a baby and cant be a dragon rider. So thats why she cant be a dragon rider so tell me why Roran and Arya cant be the last rider

im not saying it cant be im saying it might not be them not cant

Its a dead subject its not gunna be elva i think its obvious im done argueing lol this is my last post on this topic weve been rumbling around for like 2 pages lol

lol ok were done

DO U KNOW WHAT MAKES ME ANGRY!!! i had a great idea or opinion as you would say and it would have been a good topic but with our arguing i forgot it
!

ouch thats gotta suck real bad now im missing it

No no i got it back
sweet i got a good topic

what?

im sure youve found it by now

the dragon rider thing is cool but the part with elva getting together with eragon is like soo wrong in soo many ways. it kinda makes me want to puke.

i think that the last rider is going to be roran. And if roran is a rider eragon and roran will probably travel together and train together and during that time saphira will probably mate with roran dragon
(whitch is definatly a boy).How knows they might make a new generation of riders.


THERE IS NO WAY ELVA IS GOING TO GET WITH ELVA.iT IS LIKE A PERSON IN HIGH SCHOOL GOING OUT WITH A KID IN PRESCHOOL

I agree with you. I think its Roran to.

Yes, but if eragon were to ever get with arya, it would be like a RETIRED person with someone in pre-school!

I hope its arya as the rider because then Eragon and her might be distened but with them riding together they form an unbreakable bond and then they as one as there dragons can love eachother in all aspects. Lover dragons and lover riders sounds like destiny again

I know, but it's just ALL TOO PREDICTABLE! There's bound to be a major twist!

caterpillar caterpillar MAJOR TWIST HERE!!!! Roran and Arya? I knoww I know he loves katrina but then there would be drama between eragon and roran!

Her abality to "shield others from harm" i think will prevent her from becoming a rider because she might kill herself to save her dragon and then the dragon would suffer as well

Yes, but eragon said he would lift the curse/blessing thing.

yes, thats right. i still think arya is the next rider, because both she and eragon are going to live forever. who cares if shes older. they are pretty much the same age because of immortality

i agree with the were-wolf if Elva was to become a rider she would be very powerful cos of the mark on the forehead

elva "could" b the next ridr then she would b like totally sweet at magic, but she will not hook up with Eragon....GROSS!!! he was 16 wen she was like 1.....ewwwww........ i like the idea of roran being the next ridr 2, then saphira could mate with rorans dragon "greeny" and they could make new dragons...(who could possibly hatch for elva)

roran won't become the next rider i think
as for elva i think the book won't say so there will up to us to decide

Saphira 75; maybe Elva will be next rider and get with Eragon

When you say "and get with Eragon", what is it exactly what you mean here?

Is is "get together" like in Eragon and Arya?

yeah it means maybe shes the next rider and have a relatesonship with eragon

SORRY BUT I DON'T THINK SO!!!!!

I'm with AnnieBee, Elva is way too young to be with Eragon and what makes you think Eragon would want to be with her? Also, she was already given a gift from a rider and dragon and the gift was too help when ppl were in pain. . . how could you think she would become a dragon rider?

i reckon it won't say unless theres a book about it
note: this is about her being a rider not being with eragon

I'm with you 2 too, she is way too young, and even though she grows and ages faster than normal, she would still be too young to fit in the last book as a grownup

Actually, it's about her possibly being a rider and getting with Eragon. Check the title before you post, so you don't end up making a fool of yourself.

Also i think Eragon loves Arya way to much to ever think about being with someone else

Okay, the thought that Eragon would go for Elva is a bit bizzare for me. I know she has special growing powers due to the blessing/curse, but I do not see it happening. I do not think Eragon is that flighty;

Mental Picture:
Eragon: OK, since I can't have Arya, I need to pick someone else.
Saphira: She needs to be wise, of noble birth....
Eragon: What do you think of Nasuada? Our children will be really cute, and she's of noble birth!
Saphira: No, I got he match made in Heaven, excuse me, in the Void, I forgot elves don't believe
in heaven, how about Elva?
Eragon: What, Elva? No, I don't think so. She scares me!!!!

i think elva being rider has possibility.

no, in an interviev cp said elva wasn't in the original storline and he made her up on the spot, he said she will not be important in book 3.

ok. this is creepy. Eragon is NOT a pediophile. the image is just wrong. *shudders*

this is what i have to say abouyt this theary 1 elva is waaaay to young for eragon 2 arya will be greenys dragon rider and 3 eragon luvs arya not elva

that's true. and the prophesy has already been fufilled, so if he really doesn't get together with Arya (which I am sure he will), then he doesn't have to fall for anyone else.

I don't know. Elva will certainly have an important role, but I don't think she'll be the next Rider.

ur joking right?