A new villain, hmmmmmmmmmm
1st thought was Roran, maybe katrina dies and he goes mad? Nah probably not
New villain, what does he mean, does it mean a new person, It must mean someone we know if its a surprise?

it could be like another shade or razzac.

Wasn't Durza the last shade? Maby its Murtag

mutragh already is a villian. and no durza wasnt the last shade

hmm a new villain ey... can this be why eragon decides to leave alagaesia forever? Doubt it though, cuz i dont think eragon would cower away from an enemy.

Katrina who has been brainwashed.

probably someone from the other land that ragon was supposed to go to

Could be. but think of this if Trianna becomes a shade. It would be a huge suprise and I dont think many would see it coming.

what about the ra'ack parents?they havn't really been that much talked baout.and the preview from eldest talkls about them a little.

i agree with silverwolf because katrina has prolly been brainwashed when with galby

I don't think she's powerful enough to be a villain. What about the Varden? Someone in there could be a villian? You know? Or somebody we've stumbled on, maybe Orik?

ya it could be trinna

Thank you but now the question is how did she become a shade or just swich sides.

there could be another shade..... but i think she'll just swich sides...

it has to b a very strong villan...i dnt see y CP has to add another tho....he's alreadi got the Raz'zac (who i think will die), Galby n Murtagh, does the book reali need a new villan?????

not really... but its something to keep us thinking until the book acually comes out lol

mmmmm....i suppose so but y would he add another 1...i dnt reali c the point in CP addind another...it would complicate things and add another possibility of defeat for Eragon

That is why the adding of another villan would not be expected, even more if it came from a character who was already established as somone good and did not meen to turn evil so I think it would be Trinna.

The way I think it would happen is while fighting the Twins in Eldist she made an atempt to sommon a spirt far more powerful than she, making her a shade. Then Eragon could not see the her coming if she atacked because he trusts her. So Arya would save Eragon by killing Trinna. One of the ways I have thought of.
Do you think Im wright.

she didnt kill the twins roran did

I never said she Killed them but fought them and while fighting (it could have been at a distance) she summoned a spirt a lot more powerful than she and it took control of her, she was close to Arya mostlikly durring the fighting and she must of known that she was no match for her and is waighting for the right moment to strike. That is if this is what happend.

That could of happened I suppose. But that distracted them enough for Roran to come hammering in.

are you talking about Trianna or are you calling Katrina Trinna?

What if Murtagh becomes the big villian at the end?

that would be a twist in the story. you think hes turning good but at the last minute he says just kidding and is evil again. It's crazy, i tell you, crazy

no trinna is one of the vardens magicains

whoever it is.... they r jus another barrier between Eragon n killing Galby.....

Or he could be the person behind Galby? LIke Galby could be his puppet whoever it is.

Are you talking about some one controling Galby and his actions?

no thats unlikely. it would be stupid for all this to be about galby and then all the sudden we relize theres some one bigger.

Yes it would but I didn't understand if that is what scarecrow was saying.

But it could happen though, someone else stronger than Galby could be using him, but I really don't think that would happen in the books though. It would be cool.

But that would make things way to complicated and it is all ready confusing me

well the thing is the would be no reason for him to hide if he is that string considering how strong galby is.

That is very true unless he is afraid of Eragon because he was traind by Brom the only person who was powerful enough to take down the Forsworn.

no thats unlikely remember that the forsworn wernt nearly as powerful as galby and brom wasnt the only one who killed some them but he did kill a lot.

True but he did the most damage. It is unlikly but I was only saying the way I think it would be if it were true.

Just forget what I said.

if Galby has some1 using him as a puppet...thn wouldnt that person be like super powerful....i dnt think Eragon would stand no chance...i dnt think some1 would b in charge of Galby mayb some1 is being controlled by Galby but i dno if some1 could control Galby himself

But maybe Galby gets his powers through that one person but I don't think it'll happen so forget what I said.

Maybe the Shade who tought him is using him that is the only way I see it happening.

That could be. We don't even know what happened to that Shade.

True but we don't know if he is dead and he in my book is the one (if someone is controling Galby) who would be powerful enough in dark magic to be capable.

The Shade maybe that gave him more powers?

Yes that is the one because if he already knew the extent of the powers he could of had Galby swear in the ancent language to serve him.

yea and glby might be hipnotized to bring back the shade, or anything similar to that

what do you mean by bring back?

that galby might raise the shade and bring him back

But we don't know if he is dead.

ya i think we do and also remember bringing back some one would kill you

But not even the elves know all the secrets of magic so there is a possibility that someone can be brought back it highly unlikly but still a possibilty.

thats where galby's energy storage thingy could fit in.... he has enought stored to bring him back without killing himself....

But what I am saying is that there is some unkown spell out there that brings people back to life.

possibly i mean look at all the spells that murtagh knew that eragon never heard of...

True but I don't think Galby will ever be capable to resurecte someone. Thats Eragon's Job

ok well you just changed your whole opinion o this subject lol ..... ehhh anythings possible

Oh I thought you were comenting on past coments not the topic what is the topic.

rezing the shade i think...

It is who could be a new villain which I think will be Trianna, she turns in to a shade.

well can't any1 turn into a shade ... dark spirits just have to posses the person right?

but she is the most likly to and no not every one can turn into a shade only ones who can summon and controle spirits can I think.

yeah trianna is too power hungry

I don't think she is power hungry put your self in her shoes how would you reacte if you held some power and had it striped from you even though she didn't.

Who's trinna? I forget who she is.

shes one of the vardens head magicians

Oh, well how would she have so much power? And would you want her to have alot of power?

you never know. the same thing could happen as what happened to murtagh

Murtagh is getting his power from Galby which is getting his powers from something else.

scarecrow go to ddg

i dont think balby is getting his power from something else

No she won't incress her power but the spirt will incress his with her when it takes controle of her.

I do because he is certainly giving his powers to Murtagh.


And why?

because i have something for you

Let's get back on topic and no.

Should I leave you two alone in here Couse you are scaring me

dont make me reoprt you

Quit being stupid and let's get back on topic. Or I"LL REPORT YOU!!!

Trinna In my opinion will be the next new villain if any one is.

Maybe, or maybe Murtagh will become the major villian.

why would you reoprt me or going off topic

do it or ill report you

What am I doing?

And yes, you were a mod!!! It's against the rules to go off topic!!!

But he is already a villain maybe not by choice but he still is a villain and a powerful one at that.

That is why I'm saying he'll become a major one!!

your not doing what i told you to do and do it now or else. man your such a nuesence

he already is basicly

I don't understand what you mean.

Yes but once Galby dies he will become a major one.

I think if Galby dies he would aready be good or will be dead.

I don't know, I need to read the third book.

reported

murtagh is already a major villin bacicly

Ok that was stupid.

But I'm saying once Galby dies he will be the major one.

*cough*ddg*cough*

if you mean the primay one i know what you mean

No

Anyway I know he will be the major one once Galby dies.

fine you will just get a warning

No I won't. And let's get back on topic.

sorry i wouldnt report him here but theres nothing else to report. wont happen again. now if scarecrow will do it for god sake ill be happy.

any way back on topic

murtagh is already a major villan but if galby dies first (which i think he wont) murtagh will be the main villan

So your trying to look for something to report on? How ridiculous!!!

Sorry Annie won't happen again, and believe me I've tried staying on topic.

I agree with what you said RPM.

I don't know, I don't think galby could have twisted his mind that much, Wait he is morzan's son so he is weak in the head so I agree.