I put no unless in book 3 Eragon gets really powerful (magic) and he trys to bring brom back but remember in Angelas sotry tellin she said he would never come back to algaesia after he left....

Önly a fool like Eragon will try to ressurect someone...

lol yah

ye that so true lol!!!

He might, I certainly hope so. It seems unlikely, but since we know someone will rise again . . .

So sacrifice...how sweet

I don't think it would be right, he had no part in eldest because he was dead, so it would be strange if he came back in Empire.

but he is in sterile place-no worms no harm for body

lol that's not the point! The point is that he was practically forgotten in eldest, it would be strange to bring him back- it would be like skipping a book!

ye but think about it i read i nreviews that they r conparing it to LOTRs so it would make sense and no that he is making the PRE-quel ( like jrr made the HObbit) it just makes it work dont you think??

I don't really like the entire concept of being able to raise someone from the dead. Maybe he won't be technically "reborn," but Eragon'll meet him in the Vault of Souls.

Vault of souls? what is that

Ye ur rite i thought about that too!!!
um well you said u havnt finished Eldest yet so mayb ull find out soon!!

Nobody KNOWS what the vault of souls is yet, but remember in Eragon when solembum told him about the menoa tree and the vault of souls? If you forgot, I would seriously advise you read it again!

no

And what about finding Broms old sword under the menoa tree which will also contain all things that Brom ever knew?

under the menoa tree is the wepon eragon will use to defeat gallby and the vault of souls is where eragon will find his mothers spirt

No, I do not believe for a minute Brom will come back from the dead. This plotline would mess up the whole story. So far Galbatorix is the strongest one alive; don't you think if he could he would bring back Morzan, his most faithfull forsworn? No, I don't think it is possible.

I don't think it could be Brom for all we know it might be Murtagh...
I mean if Murtagh stands in Eragons way...
Murtagh is stronger...
so Eragon will need to fight his way out of it and overpowering...
thats harder than killing...

no, i disagree. he wont come back. eragon would have to look all over Alagaesia for his grave. i think he might meet his spirot with ther help of "The Mourning Sage"

wat

IMO the VOS is where all the souls Galbatorix has killed, maybe even all those under his command have killed. This is what gives him the ability to ever increase his power. Eragon will open the VOS and release these spirits. Will Brom come back no if he did Lucas will have a fit and call for plagerism as the plot line is already enough like Star Wars.

When did it say someone will rise again?

he could make Brom return with a bunch of wizards and the new rider

noone nomatter how hard they tried or how many people were used could they resurect someone they would all die so i reckon he only sees brom and his mother at the vault of souls

i don't think so but i want it sooo much (he is my favorite character)

me 2 i like brom

I think Eragon might be able to bring Brom back by using his namesakes' powers.It wouldn't really be out of place if you think about it.

One of the rules of magic is that this is IMPOSSIBLE.

I think he will, considering it forshodows a little bit when he gets encased in diamond and stuff so his body will be preserved. You have to think about it.

if eragon knew broms name he might be able to resurect brom but...no one ever said anything about resurecting brom with magic did they, person that calls themself I'MNOTCRAZY?

what? me? yeah. that's my screen name. you can shorten it to IMNC. I'MNOTCRAZY is a bit tedious to write.

he can't. It is a rule of magic that it is impossible and you WILL die if you attempt it. Knowing someone's true name does not change the rules of magic.

I DONT THINK SO BUT i think Brom is Eragons Father cuz he says that he knew Eragons mom well enough when she died.

actually the sword under the tree is the first eragons sword


also brom DIED hes not coming back!

not only that but eragons father has been to ellesmera, and morzan never went there, and brom did

Every story has 2 have somthing odd happen 2 at least one character so why not brom comeing back 2 life it would be good for eragon and strange and it would make the story 10x more interesting

culd eragon not like get broms spirit from the vault of souls and put it back into broms body wit magic?

it would be an encredibly foolish thing to try, i meen eragon would be foolish enought to try it if he found out brom was his father , but i seriously doubt saphira would even let him concider it.

i think he may speek to brom at the vault of souls, but it would be like a cheesy shortcut if brom was reserected.

yeah it wuld be cheesy all this crying cuz every1 so happy 2 c brom lol

I don't think he will come back to life, but he might come back in visions or something

i hope brom does sumting heroic as a spirit in the end

He is Dead, his time is up, he is spoiled meat by now.

I do not think Brom is coming back unless the Vault of Souls has some resurrection power or something...

Yeah, that would work except how would the sould get beck inside the body?