What do you think ; is Brom Eragon's father?

It's not immposible there are some clues that could be good arguments, but if he is wouldnt Angela when she predicted Brom's death, have said it would be the death of a family member?

there is already a topic on this

i wish i was a moderater so i could say

LOCKED

but im not.

There is a 50/50 chance that Brom is Eragons father. Though I say that he is.

How do you know he's Eragon's father? I mean Angela said that some friend would die not family member.

What means 'moderater'?

dont double post

anyways a moderator is someone who upholds the rules

they lock topics and tell you to stop doing things when you do things wrong.

Brom is NOT Eragon's father. End of story....... the story would totally lose a lot if that was the case...

agreed

maybe maybe not, one thing i do hope is that arya is the next rider.

brom is eragons father but i cant share the evidence cos theres to much!!!!!! lol

For DRAGONMASTER: At the end of book Murtagh says that Morzan's his and Eragon's father. So why would be Brom?

Evidence? Do tell.

you know when someon(i 4got who) said brom loved a woman, but his love made the woman go away or something like that lol so he didnt have any children. so i think brom is NOT eragon's father.

I remember vaguely something like that, but not the details..

Could be

Angela said that and it was like "He [Brom] loved a woman but his affection for her was ultimately her undoing." I'm not sure who the father is but if it Brom then I agree, the story would lose a lot.

Who do you guys think will be the third rider? I think it's between Roran bcz of family traits. Or Katrina bcz she was taken by the monsters and know one seems in a possesion to take the flast egg then were she is right now, in the bad guys cave. Christopher also said that their are female dragon riders.

Well yeah. It's also more likely for the rider to be an elf. *cough* Arya *cough*

Ok time to get back on topic! I'm kinda half on half with Eragon's daddy....I mean Brom's side is overwelming and Morzan's is good too but....I'm so confused lol! Also on Angela's reading it said and I quote (Eragon Pg:204) "There's is a doom upon you, but of the what sort I know not. Part of it lies in a death-one that rapidly approaches and will cause you grief." She was talking about Brom but never said if it was a friend or family member. Just that it would cause much grief.

i agree with midnite_hero cos angela wasn't that clear if it was gonna b a family member or his long lost family memba

No!! i dont think brom is eragons father

Eragon rocks

please, don't post twice within 24 hours, and 5 words or more, on topic and relevant. i know your new, but try to obey the rules



i hate it when people say katrina, she couldn't do anything. its definetly arya.

I agree with Seige, it is definitely Arya. hands down.

dude eragons father ain't brom. Eragons father is eragon

try a couple thousand--give or take a few centuries.

and yes, the next rider IS arya. don't fight the inevitable. Same with Brom-He IS eragon's father.

No it is not going to be arya!
And Brom is not Eragons father Morzan is!
Guys you have to come to grips with is.

I only agree half with you. The next rider shall be Arya, whilst Eragon's father is NOT, I repeat, NOT Brom.

Nobody wants to accept the truth about this.

Here we go again, time for some seriosly proving wrong of noobs.

1. lived centuries ago
2. since he was so famuos people would know who his son was.
3. the first rider was an elf
4. its morzan

thats bacically it. 1 pretty much completely proves it wrong anyway.

hadent we already proved him wrong?